Bakery

Notice About Fresh Produce: Inventory may be limited depending on demand, but we'll be restocking produce and other goods multiple times per week.

Notice About Flowers: We're working to get flowers and vegetable plants listed on our Online Store. While we're closed for in-person grocery shopping, we welcome you to explore our flower selection outdoors (face mask required for service).

All ProductsBakeryDairyProduceMeatsSpreads & PreservesOther GroceryOther GoodsFlowers
View Cart
0

Creekside Farm is proud to offer a variety of Thanksgiving pies!

Please fill out the order form below to preorder your pies. Please note that we are accepting preorders until 5pm on Saturday, November 17th. Due to increased Thanksgiving volume, pies will not be available for purchase unless preordered.

Our 9" pies cost $13.95 and may be picked up on Tuesday 11/20 or Wednesday 11/21.

We will be offering
the following pies:
Apple
Apple Crisp
Apple (No Sugar Added)
Cherry Crumb
Dutch Blueberry
Mixed Berry
Peach Praline
Pumpkin
Strawberry Rhubarb

Loaf Cakes:
Banana Nut
Cranberry Orange
Pumpkin
Zucchini Nut

We are located at 431 Southern Boulevard in Chatham, NJ (across from Fairmont Country Club). We look forward to being a small part of your Thanksgiving celebration!

Specialty Breads
On Sale
Specialty Breads
$ 2.99 USD
Try one of our specialty breads: Classic Baguette, Sourdough Boule, or Classic Ciabatta
*Not available for Same Day Pickup as bakery items are made-to-order.
Gourmet Bread
On Sale
Gourmet Bread
$ 6.99 USD
This gourmet bread is delicately flavored with fruits and spices
*Not available for Same Day Pickup as bakery items are made-to-order.
Old Mill Cheesecake
On Sale
Old Mill Cheesecake
$ 19.99 USD
9" Amish Crafted Cheesecake 
*Not available for Same Day Pickup as bakery items are made-to-order.
Sliced Bread
On Sale
Sliced Bread
$ 4.49 USD
Farm fresh sliced bread
*Not available for Same Day Pickup as bakery items are made-to-order.
9" Fresh Baked Pies
On Sale
9" Fresh Baked Pies
$ 13.95 USD
Our famous, freshly baked 9" Pies are great any time of the year
*Not available for Same Day Pickup as bakery items are made-to-order.
Apple Cider Donuts
On Sale
Apple Cider Donuts
$ 5.49 USD
Take home some of our customer-favorite Apple Cider Donuts, variety pack (2 plain, 2 cinnamon, 2 powdered)
*Not available for Same Day Pickup as bakery items are made-to-order.
Large Whoopie Pies (Pack of 4)
On Sale
Large Whoopie Pies (Pack of 4)
$ 5.99 USD
Arianna's Bakery Pack of 4 Large Whoopie Pies
*Not available for Same Day Pickup as bakery items are made-to-order.
Loaf Cakes
On Sale
Loaf Cakes
$ 6.49 USD
Our delicious, moist loaf cakes make five to seven slices
*Not available for Same Day Pickup as bakery items are made-to-order.
Mini Whoopie Pies
On Sale
Mini Whoopie Pies
$ 7.99 USD
12 count of Windy Hill Mini Whoopie Pies
*Not available for Same Day Pickup as bakery items are made-to-order.
Muffins
On Sale
Muffins
$ 1.99 USD
Individually packed 6.25 oz moist muffins in Chocolate Chip or Blueberry
*Not available for Same Day Pickup as bakery items are made-to-order.
Crumb Cake
On Sale
Crumb Cake
$ 1.99 USD
Our own buttery, crumbly Crumb Cake
*Not available for Same Day Pickup as bakery items are made-to-order.
powered by Typeform